1998 is the 85th anniversary of the
constitutional amendment allowing the federal income tax. And
Americans wibder what its purpose is.
The benefits of income tax are that
whiskey cigars, caviar, sable coats, champagne, truffles, brie,
Rolls-Royce, Oriental rugs, emeralds and English butlers cost
you a lot less than if we didn’t have federal income tax. If
you don’t have those things, it is jut one more unfair aspect
of federal income taxes.
From 1776 until 1913 the federal government paid its way with
levies on liquor and tobacco and with excise taxes on fancy
imported goods and foreign servants.
During this period the U.S. rose from a small group of states
to become the most powerful nation in the world. Occassionally
there was not enough money to pay all the bills, so the
government would just print extra money. When this happened,
bankers took a hit because the interest they were receiving from
loans now was worth a bit less. Bankers never like to lose
money, so a bunch of international bankers got together and
formulated a plan that they thought would help the nation’s
economy, but most importantly would keep them from losing money
and perhaps make them a bit of profit.
The plan involved a federal income tax and the Federal
Reserve Board.
The plan was that when the economy was in resession, the
government would borrow
money from the Federal Reserve and plow it back into the
economy. And when the economy was expanding, the government
would tax the public and use the money to pay back the loans.
In order to make this plan work, the U.S. Constitution had to
be changed, because our founding fathers specifically banned
federal income tax twice in the Constitution.
In 1913, after several years of lobbying
(i.e. giving lots of money to Congressmen) by banking
organizations, Congress created the Federal Reserve System. and
gave its bankers the power to control the nation’s economy.
At this same time, under the guidance of bankers and
political centerists a Constitutional Amendment was being
circulated throughout the states.
This 16th Amendement was neveral lawfully ratified by the
three-forths of the states as required by the Constitution. Many
of the states did not follow lawful procedure in ratifying the
Amendment. Others made changes in the Amendment before they
ratified it. Ultimately only two state lawfully ratified the
Amendment as set forth by Congress.
In the late winter of 1913, despite these facts and no doubt
because he was under pressure by the commercial banks, Secretary
of State Finlander Knox stood before
Only a small percentage of wage earners had to pay the income
tax originally imposed by Congress Americans didn’t have to
pay any tax unless they earned more than $4000 (the equivalent
of $65.000 toady), and that first tax bracket was merely one
percent. Great numbers of Americans then
The seven percent rate applied only to people earning more
than $500,000.(eight million dollars today) And in 1913 that
included the Rockefellers, Carnegies, Mellons, Morgans, Goulds,
Vanderbilts and almost no one else
It took Congress just three years to bump the rate up to 15
percent. In one more year it soared to 67 %. Of course, that was
only for incomes above $2 million (the same as 32 million dollar
today) Unfortunately this brilliant plan to stablize the
enconomy did not work. In 1929 the U.S. was hit with the worst
depression in history and hundreds of bankers went bankrupt.
But this did not bring an end to federal income tax or the
Federal Reserve. This system was a monster and like the monsters
of myth, it could not be killed. It just kept growing larger.
Once members ol Congress learned whal a nifty money maker the
income tax was for the federal government there was no stopping
them
When the nation entered World War II, income tax was imposed
upon the average wage earner. and surpizingly enough, they were
quite tolerant of this tax on their incomes. for it was a modest
bite and, after all, there was a war going on.
In one swoop, the government added 50 million new taxpayers
to the rolls, people of moderate incomes.
The rate in 1943 was 19% on earnings of $2,000. It would be
similar to paying a
tax of one-fifth on an income of $18,555 in today’s
dollars. The rate went up to 88% on incomes of more than
$200,000, a salary the equivalent of $1.8 million today.
The only problem to this huge windfall of new income for
Washington was that there was no good system for collecting all
that money. Before World War II, taxes were paid on a monthly
basis. Everybody had to fill out forms and mail in their taxes,
much like the self-employed today, who must send in quarterly
payments.
Then Congress came up with withholding - the cleverest, most
significant innovation of government bureaucracy ever.
Withholding was created 54 years ago, in June 1943, when
Congress passed the Current Tax Payment Act. It provided for a
20% withholding tax. It also included a forgiveness of 75% of
either the 1942 or 1943 tax liability, whichever was smaller.
In effect, Congress was saying, We know you don’t have the
money to suddenly pay all this tax, so we’ll let you off the
hook by taking only 25% of what you didn’t know you already
owed, and we’ll only take from your pay, before you even get
it, 20% from now on. We’ll take the burden of figuring it out
off of your shoulders.
In other words: "We’re from Washington, trust
us."
And, behold, today, when taxpayers get refunds on their
taxes, many are glad. As if they had forgotten that it was their
money in the first place, not a gift from the government.
As former historian of the Internal Revenue Service, Shelly
Davis, says, "I truly believe our income tax system would
completely fall apart if not for withholding. Without
withholding, we would be able to sustain our tax system as it
exists. Without that, there would be absolutely no way for the
IRS to collect well over one trillion dollars annually from
taxpayers today.".
And remember, the 16th Amendment - The Federal Income Tax
Amendment - was never lawfully ratified, so actually federal
income tax is still unconstitutional. As this fact is becoming
more widely known, the IRS is beginning to pull back its troops
and is considering actually going out of business or at least
trimming down.